proportionality
... to insist on proportionality in warfare does not imply that the Air Force can only use radar if the enemy has it as well. Rather, it means that ... oh let me try to think of an exaggerated example just to make the point ... Okay I've got it! Proportionality in warfare means that if a foreign government bombs a military target and kills a few thousand of your soldiers, then you're not allowed to turn around, invent atomic weapons and use them to melt tens of thousands of children who are subjects of that same government, particularly when you've already blockaded their mainland and their troops are no longer a threat. There ... If that ridiculous example doesn't get the idea across, I don't know what else will.
- Bob Murphy, "Muddled Michael Medved"
See also Tom Woods, "Another Conservative Contribution to Civilization":Ah, what intellectuals today's conservatives are, always brimming with erudition. In a recent column, Michael Medved speaks of the idea of proportionate response as a criterion of the just war as a "currently trendy notion" and a "misguided contemporary" tool of moral evaluation. How embarrassed we all must feel to have thought it came from Hugo Grotius (1583-1645).And on questioning the justice and goodness of WWII:
Those are pretty good questions, actually, even if the entire range of respectable opinion forbids us to pose them. Some issues, you understand, can never be discussed or considered lest society revert instantly to barbarism.















1 Comments:
At Mises University, a Swedish student named Carl Jakobsson and I discussed this and he said that in war, the issue is not one of proportionality at all. It is not a matter of A aggressing against B and then B using violence against A, either proportionally or not. It is rather A using violence against C, D, E, F. . . and B using violence against Z, Y, X, W. . . .
My corollary: Even if one belligerent responds to an attack against 100 innocents of his country by killing merely 10 innocents of the other country, does that make it "proportional"? What does that even mean? Proportionality, as is most often used in discussions about war, is a collectivist concept, whereby "we" can only kill as many of "them" as "they" kill of "us." We libertarians should be cautious of our use of this term.
Post a Comment
<< Home